This site uses cookies. By continuing, your consent is assumed. Learn more

130.4m shares

Carbon dating stone

opinion

By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and Carbon dating stone our Cookie PolicyPrivacy Policyand our Terms of Service. This is what I've read in an article won't share it here out of fear of attracting several downvotes just for posting a link of that kind that raises some questions:. Carbon dating is carried out on organic matter found around, inside or near Carbon dating stone stone object.

Because radiocarbon dating is limited...

Based on that organic material's dating, the date around which the item was carved, is estimated. The problem with Carbon dating stone approach: Suppose a museum in the present day has several stone monuments from varying dates.

And they're cleaned and maintained quite well by the curator; there is no organic material on them. One day the whole museum is suddenly buried under enormous amounts Carbon dating stone inorganic material, with Carbon dating stone curator trapped in and crushed to death.

The only organic material they find is the remains of the curator. They date it, and from that, peg all Carbon dating stone stone sculptures found in the museum at years old. But the items were actually much older than even the curator. So isn't that a wrong dating? Inspecting the handiwork on the sculpture itself is subjective to assumptions about possession of skills at different time periods.

Take one present day example: Utensils from years ago in a museum can have exquisite artwork, embellishment, detailing. Imagine someone comparing it with a Carbon dating stone being ordinarily used today having no artwork, with both items being made of the same material.

They would assume that today's utensil is older than the one from years ago, on the basis of handiwork. So is the part about the carbon dating of nearby organic material true? Or does stone have its own ways of finding age of Carbon dating stone that is independent of nearby organic material?

First of all, carbon dating is a highly inexact science to begin with. If you submit identical samples to different labs you will get widely differing results. Also, all labs I know of require the Carbon dating stone to describe where the sample came from and provide an estimated age of the sample. In fact, a lot Carbon dating stone labs not only require you to estimate the age of the sample, they require you to justify your estimate.

Obviously, this is not scientific. A scientific measurement is "blind", Carbon dating stone the tester does not what the result should be ahead of time; carbon dating does not fall into this category. As far as stratigraphy is concerned, Carbon dating stone remains, the kind of error you describe are always a concern. Usually any kind of single piece of evidence is not sufficient Carbon dating stone date an object; an overwhelming and diversified set of evidence is necessary.

For example, if a bone is found in Carbon dating stone tomb, that is not enough to date the construction of the tomb, because the bone could have been placed in the tomb long after it was constructed. There is no way to date a stone carving based on just the stone itself, because the chemistry of the situation is too variable and too complex. For example, moisture and temperature fluctuation will have a Carbon dating Carbon dating stone effect on how a stone weathers.

So, one excavated stone might look brand new, and another one very ancient and degraded. Carbon dating stone stone carvings are dated either on the basis of style or on the archaeological context they are found in. A lot of crafted items can be reasonably Carbon dating stone by how they were made, and what they were made of.

How readily available a given material in this case, stone is can be influenced by a lot of factors: The item's time period of origin can be narrowed down by substances found in adjacent sediment deposits and carbon dating of these substances left in the deposits on the object itself. By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of serviceprivacy policy and cookie policyand that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Home Questions Tags Users Unanswered. How can one reliably date a carved stone item or structure? This is what I've read in an article won't share it here out of fear of attracting several downvotes just for posting a link of that kind Carbon dating stone raises some questions: Carbon dating stone VJ 2 9.

For radiocarbon dating to be...

Firstly, no one would assume that a simplistic design must necessarily predate an elaborate one. In Carbon dating stone, we Carbon dating stone study at the design itself, and try to ascertain whether it resembles trends that are known to be fashionable in a particular Carbon dating stone. Secondly, carbon dating of nearby objects is a tool, not to be taken as absolute gospel.

It would be incredibly careless to date stylistically disparate monuments in a museum by some organic matter that happens to be nearby.

I merely shared a hypothetical situation to illustrate the problem which you further confirmed. And don't underestimate the naivette of high prestige.

“This technique stands to revolutionize...

Carbon dating stone Here's an alternative situation, perhaps it'll pass your test: It gets rediscovered many centuries later, and dating pegs it to the thief's time period. The artefact is one-of-a-kind, and cannot be reliably linked with any other known artistry by the team studying it. I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because it asks about an imaginary hypothetical scenario. The question itself isn't hypothetical at all. The examples situations which might be offending you are important to clarify an important doubt.

There are many folks out there including educators who wrongly believe that carbon dating can be used on the stone itself without any need for organic material to be around.

This question has had a fairly large number of views, showing that there is interest. There might not be a clear answer but that's ok. I humbly request you to let it be. I guess the expression "timelessness" really comes to life then Carbon dating stone things made of stone.

Carbon dating stone is pretty much it. Carbon dating stone dating stone deposits in layers.

What can be dated?

Everything in the same Carbon dating stone is likely left there at roughly the same time kind of like rings on a tree. So Carbon dating stone only have to carbon or isotope-date something in that layer, and you have a pretty good estimate for the date of everything in that layer. See stratigraphy for more information.

Radiocarbon dating is a method...

Now what if a clean stone sculpture got sediment-deposited years AFTER it was made, because till then the people around it made sure it didn't get sediment-deposited? Thanks for suggesting the other more social angles, but my question was specifically asking whether dating the stone item itself is possible or not.

In the exceedingly implausible event that something was cleaned so thoroughly as to be purged of all residue, a number of possibilities for close dating still exist, but they are not technological. While the stone material existing in your hypothetical scenario could be sourced Carbon dating stone based on Carbon dating stone differences Carbon dating stone it's composition, a timestamp on when crafting Carbon dating stone place would be impossible.

A lot of stonework that is in a not dissimilar situation of being uncovered or cleaned can be dated by it's own record; think the Sphinx. Not quite - you obtain a pretty good minimum age for everything Carbon dating stone the layer, assuming no Carbon dating stone of prior layer mixing or disturbance. The surface of a stone gradually changes with exposure to air. Carved Carbon dating stone will show less "patina".

Try to Carbon dating stone rate of change in the patina. Although this may be a good start for an answer, this post badly needs further expansion.

You've got the right idea....

Sign up or log in Sign up using Google. Sign up using Facebook. Sign up using Email and Password. Post Carbon dating stone a guest Name. Email Required, Carbon dating stone never shown.

Post Your Answer Discard By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of serviceprivacy policy and cookie policyand that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies. History Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled.

MORE: Is emma stone dating bradley cooper

News feed